Toronto Blue Jays @ New York Yankees — May 19, 2026 player props & results

Final: TOR 4 NYY 5

Frozen archive — lines & results as of May 19, 2026, 5:36 PM ET.

The props and game lines below were on the board at first pitch. Each shows its closing line, the best available price across the sportsbooks we track, and the actual result. Hit/Miss/Push reflects the official box score — a player who did not appear (or did not pitch, for a pitcher market) shows “—”, never an invented result. Results and frequencies only, never picks.

Hits

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Aaron Judge Under 0.5 0 — Hit +172 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -200 Miss · O1.5 +270 Miss · O2.5 +1400 Miss · O3.5 +8000 Miss
Andres Gimenez Under 0.5 +130 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -170 · O1.5 +350 · O2.5 +2000 · O3.5 +12500
Anthony Volpe Under 0.5 1 — Miss +108 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -130 Hit · O1.5 +500 Miss · O2.5 +3300 Miss
Austin Wells Under 0.5 0 — Hit -136 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +103 Miss · O1.5 +700 Miss · O2.5 +5000 Miss
Ben Rice Under 0.5 1 — Miss +159 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -190 Hit · O1.5 +290 Miss · O2.5 +1700 Miss · O3.5 +10000 Miss
Cody Bellinger Under 0.5 1 — Miss +145 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -194 Hit · O1.5 +293 Miss · O2.5 +1500 Miss · O3.5 +8000 Miss
Daulton Varsho Under 0.5 4 — Miss +168 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -210 Hit · O1.5 +270 Hit · O2.5 +1600 Hit · O3.5 +10000 Hit
Davis Schneider Under 0.5 0 — Hit -116 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -115 Miss · O1.5 +503 Miss · O2.5 +3000 Miss · O3.5 +20000 Miss
George Springer Under 0.5 1 — Miss +191 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -230 Hit · O1.5 +230 Miss · O2.5 +1100 Miss · O3.5 +6500 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Under 0.5 0 — Hit +117 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -150 Miss · O1.5 +420 Miss · O2.5 +2500 Miss · O3.5 +20000 Miss
Jesus Sanchez Under 0.5 +115 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -150 · O1.5 +400 · O2.5 +2200
Kazuma Okamoto Under 0.5 0 — Hit +147 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -185 Miss · O1.5 +291 Miss · O2.5 +1600 Miss · O3.5 +10000 Miss
Ryan McMahon Under 0.5 2 — Miss -101 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -131 Hit · O1.5 +500 Hit · O2.5 +3300 Miss · O3.5 +22500 Miss
Spencer Jones Under 0.5 0 — Hit -117 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -110 Miss · O1.5 +600 Miss · O2.5 +4000 Miss
Trent Grisham Under 0.5 1 — Miss +112 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -149 Hit · O1.5 +366 Miss · O2.5 +1900 Miss · O3.5 +10000 Miss
Tyler Heineman Under 0.5 0 — Hit -101 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -120 Miss · O1.5 +550 Miss · O2.5 +3500 Miss
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Under 1.5 0 — Hit -233 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -312 Miss · O1.5 +172 Miss · O2.5 +750 Miss · O3.5 +3500 Miss
Yohendrick Pinango Under 0.5 +144 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -175 · O1.5 +330 · O2.5 +1800 · O3.5 +12500

Home Runs

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Aaron Judge Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +235 Miss · O1.5 +2000 Miss · O2.5 +10000 Miss
Andres Gimenez Alternate lines
Alt: O0.5 +1040 · O1.5 +20000
Anthony Volpe Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +920 Miss · O1.5 +17500 Miss
Austin Wells Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +710 Miss · O1.5 +10000 Miss
Ben Rice Alternate lines 1
Alt: O0.5 +330 Hit · O1.5 +3000 Miss
Cody Bellinger Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +490 Miss · O1.5 +5500 Miss
Daulton Varsho Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +370 Miss · O1.5 +4000 Miss
Davis Schneider Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +592 Miss · O1.5 +7000 Miss
George Springer Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +470 Miss · O1.5 +5500 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +470 Miss · O1.5 +6000 Miss
Jesus Sanchez Alternate lines
Alt: O0.5 +540 · O1.5 +8000
Kazuma Okamoto Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +360 Miss · O1.5 +3500 Miss
Ryan McMahon Alternate lines 1
Alt: O0.5 +520 Hit · O1.5 +8000 Miss
Spencer Jones Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +710 Miss · O1.5 +10000 Miss
Trent Grisham Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +385 Miss · O1.5 +3900 Miss
Tyler Heineman Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +1200 Miss · O1.5 +25000 Miss
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +410 Miss · O1.5 +4500 Miss
Yohendrick Pinango Alternate lines
Alt: O0.5 +750 · O1.5 +10000

Total Bases

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Aaron Judge Under 1.5 0 — Hit -126 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +100 Miss · O2.5 +160 Miss · O3.5 +195 Miss · O4.5 +470 Miss
Andres Gimenez Alternate lines
Alt: O1.5 +185 · O2.5 +460 · O3.5 +750 · O4.5 +1700
Anthony Volpe Alternate lines 1
Alt: O1.5 +230 Miss · O2.5 +500 Miss · O3.5 +750 Miss · O4.5 +1800 Miss
Austin Wells Alternate lines 0
Alt: O1.5 +257 Miss · O2.5 +500 Miss · O3.5 +610 Miss · O4.5 +1800 Miss
Ben Rice Under 1.5 4 — Miss -157 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +118 Hit · O2.5 +210 Hit · O3.5 +270 Hit · O4.5 +650 Miss
Cody Bellinger Under 1.5 1 — Hit -186 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +139 Miss · O2.5 +270 Miss · O3.5 +371 Miss · O4.5 +800 Miss
Daulton Varsho Under 1.5 4 — Miss -154 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +116 Hit · O2.5 +220 Hit · O3.5 +300 Hit · O4.5 +700 Miss
Davis Schneider Alternate lines 0
Alt: O1.5 +205 Miss · O2.5 +380 Miss · O3.5 +486 Miss · O4.5 +1200 Miss
George Springer Under 1.5 1 — Hit -148 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +112 Miss · O2.5 +240 Miss · O3.5 +360 Miss · O4.5 +700 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Alternate lines 0
Alt: O1.5 +160 Miss · O2.5 +290 Miss · O3.5 +390 Miss · O4.5 +950 Miss
Jesus Sanchez Alternate lines
Alt: O1.5 +172 · O2.5 +340 · O3.5 +460 · O4.5 +1000
Kazuma Okamoto Under 1.5 0 — Hit -173 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +130 Miss · O2.5 +232 Miss · O3.5 +300 Miss · O4.5 +650 Miss
Ryan McMahon Alternate lines 5
Alt: O1.5 +190 Hit · O2.5 +370 Hit · O3.5 +470 Hit · O4.5 +1200 Hit
Spencer Jones Alternate lines 0
Alt: O1.5 +238 Miss · O2.5 +480 Miss · O3.5 +600 Miss · O4.5 +1600 Miss
Trent Grisham Alternate lines 1
Alt: O1.5 +153 Miss · O2.5 +265 Miss · O3.5 +329 Miss · O4.5 +760 Miss
Tyler Heineman Alternate lines 0
Alt: O1.5 +250 Miss · O2.5 +600 Miss · O3.5 +1000 Miss · O4.5 +2500 Miss
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Under 1.5 0 — Hit -123 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 -108 Miss · O2.5 +190 Miss · O3.5 +290 Miss · O4.5 +600 Miss
Yohendrick Pinango Alternate lines
Alt: O1.5 +155 · O2.5 +360 · O3.5 +550 · O4.5 +1200

Runs Scored

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Aaron Judge Under 0.5 1 — Miss -104 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -133 Hit · O1.5 +470 Miss · O2.5 +2700 Miss
Andres Gimenez Under 0.5 -234 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +190 · O1.5 +1600
Anthony Volpe Under 0.5 0 — Hit -248 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +176 Miss · O1.5 +1300 Miss
Austin Wells Under 0.5 0 — Hit -238 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +169 Miss · O1.5 +1100 Miss · O2.5 +8000 Miss
Ben Rice Under 0.5 1 — Miss -110 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -126 Hit · O1.5 +440 Miss · O2.5 +2200 Miss
Cody Bellinger Under 0.5 0 — Hit -173 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +125 Miss · O1.5 +800 Miss · O2.5 +4500 Miss
Daulton Varsho Under 0.5 1 — Miss -149 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +110 Hit · O1.5 +800 Miss · O2.5 +5000 Miss
Davis Schneider Under 0.5 0 — Hit -238 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +169 Miss · O1.5 +1000 Miss · O2.5 +7000 Miss
George Springer Under 0.5 0 — Hit -133 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -104 Miss · O1.5 +550 Miss · O2.5 +3500 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Under 0.5 1 — Miss -179 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +135 Hit · O1.5 +950 Miss · O2.5 +7000 Miss
Jesus Sanchez Under 0.5 -220 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +157 · O1.5 +1200 · O2.5 +8000
Kazuma Okamoto Under 0.5 1 — Miss -162 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +117 Hit · O1.5 +750 Miss · O2.5 +5000 Miss
Ryan McMahon Under 0.5 1 — Miss -230 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +163 Hit · O1.5 +1200 Miss
Spencer Jones Under 0.5 0 — Hit -255 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +180 Miss · O1.5 +1300 Miss · O2.5 +8000 Miss
Trent Grisham Under 0.5 1 — Miss -117 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -118 Hit · O1.5 +440 Miss · O2.5 +2500 Miss
Tyler Heineman Under 0.5 0 — Hit -267 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +195 Miss · O1.5 +1600 Miss
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Under 0.5 0 — Hit -131 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -105 Miss · O1.5 +600 Miss · O2.5 +3300 Miss
Yohendrick Pinango Under 0.5 -207 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +155 · O1.5 +1100 · O2.5 +8000

RBIs

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Aaron Judge Under 0.5 0 — Hit -162 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +120 Miss · O1.5 +323 Miss · O2.5 +800 Miss · O3.5 +1900 Miss
Andres Gimenez Under 0.5 -364 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +252 · O1.5 +850 · O2.5 +2500 · O3.5 +7500
Anthony Volpe Under 0.5 0 — Hit -369 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +253 Miss · O1.5 +850 Miss · O2.5 +2700 Miss · O3.5 +8000 Miss
Austin Wells Under 0.5 0 — Hit -438 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +296 Miss · O1.5 +870 Miss · O2.5 +2500 Miss · O3.5 +7000 Miss
Ben Rice Under 0.5 2 — Miss -223 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +160 Hit · O1.5 +470 Hit · O2.5 +1200 Miss · O3.5 +3000 Miss
Cody Bellinger Under 0.5 0 — Hit -227 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +162 Miss · O1.5 +434 Miss · O2.5 +1120 Miss · O3.5 +2700 Miss
Daulton Varsho Under 0.5 0 — Hit -207 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +155 Miss · O1.5 +480 Miss · O2.5 +1200 Miss · O3.5 +3300 Miss
Davis Schneider Under 0.5 0 — Hit -358 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +253 Miss · O1.5 +700 Miss · O2.5 +2000 Miss · O3.5 +6500 Miss
George Springer Under 0.5 0 — Hit -263 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +190 Miss · O1.5 +650 Miss · O2.5 +2000 Miss · O3.5 +6000 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Under 0.5 0 — Hit -243 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +172 Miss · O1.5 +500 Miss · O2.5 +1200 Miss · O3.5 +3000 Miss
Jesus Sanchez Under 0.5 -321 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +223 · O1.5 +650 · O2.5 +1800 · O3.5 +5000
Kazuma Okamoto Under 0.5 0 — Hit -215 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +154 Miss · O1.5 +450 Miss · O2.5 +1200 Miss · O3.5 +3000 Miss
Ryan McMahon Under 0.5 3 — Miss -299 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +209 Hit · O1.5 +600 Hit · O2.5 +1700 Hit · O3.5 +4500 Miss
Spencer Jones Under 0.5 0 — Hit -404 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +275 Miss · O1.5 +770 Miss · O2.5 +2000 Miss · O3.5 +5500 Miss
Trent Grisham Under 0.5 0 — Hit -293 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +205 Miss · O1.5 +650 Miss · O2.5 +1500 Miss · O3.5 +4000 Miss
Tyler Heineman Under 0.5 0 — Hit -438 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +296 Miss · O1.5 +1000 Miss · O2.5 +3300 Miss · O3.5 +10000 Miss
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Under 0.5 1 — Miss -219 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +165 Hit · O1.5 +550 Miss · O2.5 +1500 Miss · O3.5 +3500 Miss
Yohendrick Pinango Under 0.5 -315 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +219 · O1.5 +660 · O2.5 +2000 · O3.5 +5500

Stolen Bases

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Aaron Judge Over 0.5 0 — Miss +920 FanDuel
Andres Gimenez Over 0.5 +800 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +10000
Anthony Volpe Over 0.5 0 — Miss +400 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +3300 Miss
Ben Rice Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1280 FanDuel
Cody Bellinger Over 0.5 0 — Miss +550 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +5000 Miss
Daulton Varsho Over 0.5 1 — Hit +750 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +10000 Miss
Davis Schneider Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1200 FanDuel
George Springer Over 0.5 0 — Miss +700 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +8000 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Over 0.5 0 — Miss +310 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +2200 Miss
Jesus Sanchez Over 0.5 +680 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +10000
Kazuma Okamoto Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1100 FanDuel
Ryan McMahon Over 0.5 1 — Hit +1500 FanDuel
Spencer Jones Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1000 FanDuel
Trent Grisham Over 0.5 0 — Miss +920 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +12500 Miss
Tyler Heineman Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1260 FanDuel
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1200 FanDuel
Yohendrick Pinango Over 0.5 +880 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +12500

Hits + Runs + RBIs

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Aaron Judge Under 1.5 1 — Hit +108 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -310 Hit · O1.5 -135 Miss · O2.5 +125 Miss · O3.5 +214 Miss
Andres Gimenez Under 1.5 -151 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -220 · O1.5 +120 · O2.5 +270 · O3.5 +550
Anthony Volpe Under 1.5 1 — Hit -179 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -185 Hit · O1.5 +140 Miss · O2.5 +300 Miss · O3.5 +600 Miss
Austin Wells Under 0.5 0 — Hit +104 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -139 Miss · O1.5 +164 Miss · O2.5 +324 Miss · O3.5 +650 Miss
Ben Rice Under 1.5 4 — Miss -103 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -321 Hit · O1.5 -129 Hit · O2.5 +150 Hit · O3.5 +270 Hit
Cody Bellinger Under 1.5 1 — Hit -122 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -264 Hit · O1.5 -108 Miss · O2.5 +177 Miss · O3.5 +319 Miss
Daulton Varsho Under 1.5 5 — Miss -109 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -270 Hit · O1.5 -115 Hit · O2.5 +165 Hit · O3.5 +300 Hit
Davis Schneider Under 0.5 0 — Hit +116 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -155 Miss · O1.5 +149 Miss · O2.5 +275 Miss · O3.5 +518 Miss
George Springer Under 1.5 1 — Hit -101 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -320 Hit · O1.5 -130 Miss · O2.5 +165 Miss · O3.5 +300 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Under 1.5 1 — Hit -145 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -220 Hit · O1.5 +110 Miss · O2.5 +200 Miss · O3.5 +380 Miss
Jesus Sanchez Under 1.5 -164 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -189 · O1.5 +124 · O2.5 +233 · O3.5 +460
Kazuma Okamoto Under 1.5 1 — Hit -119 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -254 Hit · O1.5 -111 Miss · O2.5 +170 Miss · O3.5 +310 Miss
Ryan McMahon Under 0.5 6 — Miss +129 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -172 Hit · O1.5 +133 Hit · O2.5 +240 Hit · O3.5 +500 Hit
Spencer Jones Under 0.5 0 — Hit +115 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -152 Miss · O1.5 +156 Miss · O2.5 +306 Miss · O3.5 +600 Miss
Trent Grisham Under 1.5 2 — Miss -132 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -261 Hit · O1.5 -101 Hit · O2.5 +184 Miss · O3.5 +355 Miss
Tyler Heineman Under 0.5 0 — Hit +126 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -165 Miss · O1.5 +155 Miss · O2.5 +340 Miss · O3.5 +700 Miss
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Under 1.5 1 — Hit +111 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -402 Hit · O1.5 -148 Miss · O2.5 +130 Miss · O3.5 +250 Miss
Yohendrick Pinango Under 1.5 -135 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -240 · O1.5 +105 · O2.5 +220 · O3.5 +460

Strikeouts

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Dylan Cease Under 7.5 9 — Miss -136 FanDuel · 2 books
Alt: O3.5 -2300 Hit · O4.5 -780 Hit · O5.5 -343 Hit · O6.5 -171 Hit
Will Warren Under 5.5 3 — Hit -134 DraftKings · 2 books
Alt: O2.5 -1460 Hit · O3.5 -470 Miss · O4.5 -192 Miss · O5.5 +124 Miss

Outs Recorded

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Dylan Cease Over 16.5 15 — Miss +100 FanDuel · 2 books
Under 16.5 15 — Hit -118 DraftKings · 2 books
Will Warren Over 16.5 15 — Miss -130 FanDuel · 2 books
Under 16.5 15 — Hit +105 DraftKings · 2 books

Walks Allowed

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Dylan Cease Over 2.5 4 — Hit -177 DraftKings
Under 2.5 4 — Miss +133 DraftKings
Will Warren Over 1.5 1 — Miss -125 DraftKings
Under 1.5 1 — Hit -106 DraftKings

Earned Runs

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Dylan Cease Over 2.5 5 — Hit -115 DraftKings
Under 2.5 5 — Miss -116 DraftKings
Will Warren Over 2.5 3 — Hit +103 DraftKings
Under 2.5 3 — Miss -137 DraftKings

Game Lines

Moneyline

Selection Result Closing odds
NYY Hit -136 DraftKings · 2 books
TOR Miss +116 FanDuel · 2 books

Run Line

Selection Result Closing odds
NYY -1.5 Miss +150 FanDuel · 2 books
NYY -1 Push +104 DraftKings
NYY +1 Hit -185 DraftKings
TOR -1.5 Miss +196 FanDuel · 2 books
TOR -1 Miss +140 DraftKings
TOR +1 Push -135 DraftKings

Total

Selection Result Closing odds
Over 5.5 9 — Hit -438 DraftKings
Over 6 9 — Hit -395 DraftKings
Over 6.5 9 — Hit -290 DraftKings · 2 books
Under 5.5 9 — Miss +300 DraftKings
Under 6 9 — Miss +275 DraftKings
Under 6.5 9 — Miss +220 FanDuel · 2 books

Closing lines captured at the last pre-game snapshot; results from the official box score. Odds shown are the best available price across sportsbooks at that time. This is a historical record, not betting advice.