New York Yankees @ New York Mets — May 16, 2026 player props & results

Final: NYY 3 NYM 6

Frozen archive — lines & results as of May 16, 2026, 5:36 PM ET.

The props and game lines below were on the board at first pitch. Each shows its closing line, the best available price across the sportsbooks we track, and the actual result. Hit/Miss/Push reflects the official box score — a player who did not appear (or did not pitch, for a pitcher market) shows “—”, never an invented result. Results and frequencies only, never picks.

Hits

Player Bet Result Closing odds
A.J. Ewing Under 0.5 1 — Miss +103 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -125 Hit · O1.5 +500 Miss · O2.5 +3300 Miss
Aaron Judge Under 0.5 2 — Miss +196 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -260 Hit · O1.5 +200 Hit · O2.5 +900 Miss · O3.5 +4500 Miss
Amed Rosario Under 0.5 1 — Miss +125 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -167 Hit · O1.5 +331 Miss · O2.5 +1900 Miss · O3.5 +10000 Miss
Anthony Volpe Under 0.5 0 — Hit +127 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -160 Miss · O1.5 +380 Miss · O2.5 +2000 Miss · O3.5 +12500 Miss
Austin Slater Under 0.5 0 — Hit -139 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +105 Miss · O1.5 +680 Miss · O2.5 +4100 Miss
Austin Wells Under 0.5 1 — Miss -119 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -111 Hit · O1.5 +572 Miss · O2.5 +3300 Miss · O3.5 +22500 Miss
Ben Rice Under 0.5 0 — Hit +166 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -224 Miss · O1.5 +237 Miss · O2.5 +1100 Miss · O3.5 +7000 Miss
Bo Bichette Under 1.5 0 — Hit -249 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -280 Miss · O1.5 +190 Miss · O2.5 +900 Miss · O3.5 +5500 Miss
Brett Baty Under 0.5 1 — Miss +109 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -140 Hit · O1.5 +460 Miss · O2.5 +2700 Miss
Carson Benge Under 0.5 3 — Miss +137 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -183 Hit · O1.5 +305 Hit · O2.5 +1600 Hit · O3.5 +10000 Miss
Cody Bellinger Under 0.5 0 — Hit +176 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -220 Miss · O1.5 +230 Miss · O2.5 +1200 Miss · O3.5 +7000 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Under 0.5 2 — Miss +103 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -130 Hit · O1.5 +460 Hit · O2.5 +2700 Miss · O3.5 +22500 Miss
Juan Soto Under 0.5 2 — Miss +131 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -174 Hit · O1.5 +333 Hit · O2.5 +1700 Miss · O3.5 +10000 Miss
Luis Torrens Under 0.5 0 — Hit +116 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -140 Miss · O1.5 +480 Miss · O2.5 +3300 Miss · O3.5 +22500 Miss
Marcus Semien Under 0.5 0 — Hit +127 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -170 Miss · O1.5 +360 Miss · O2.5 +2000 Miss · O3.5 +15000 Miss
Mark Vientos Under 0.5 1 — Miss +157 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -180 Hit · O1.5 +340 Miss · O2.5 +1800 Miss · O3.5 +15000 Miss
Paul Goldschmidt Under 0.5 2 — Miss +144 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -180 Hit · O1.5 +310 Hit · O2.5 +1700 Miss · O3.5 +8000 Miss
Trent Grisham Under 0.5 1 — Miss +110 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -146 Hit · O1.5 +384 Miss · O2.5 +2000 Miss · O3.5 +15000 Miss

Home Runs

Player Bet Result Closing odds
A.J. Ewing Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +1040 Miss · O1.5 +25000 Miss
Aaron Judge Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +245 Miss · O1.5 +1960 Miss · O2.5 +10000 Miss
Amed Rosario Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +1360 Miss · O1.5 +30000 Miss
Anthony Volpe Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +900 Miss · O1.5 +15000 Miss
Austin Slater Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +820 Miss · O1.5 +10000 Miss
Austin Wells Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +810 Miss · O1.5 +10000 Miss
Ben Rice Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +420 Miss · O1.5 +4700 Miss
Bo Bichette Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +650 Miss · O1.5 +10000 Miss
Brett Baty Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +980 Miss · O1.5 +12500 Miss
Carson Benge Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +980 Miss · O1.5 +17500 Miss
Cody Bellinger Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +650 Miss · O1.5 +7400 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +630 Miss · O1.5 +8000 Miss
Juan Soto Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +410 Miss · O1.5 +4300 Miss
Luis Torrens Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +920 Miss · O1.5 +12500 Miss
Marcus Semien Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +680 Miss · O1.5 +12500 Miss
Mark Vientos Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +470 Miss · O1.5 +6000 Miss
Paul Goldschmidt Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +540 Miss · O1.5 +6000 Miss
Trent Grisham Alternate lines 0
Alt: O0.5 +499 Miss · O1.5 +5800 Miss

Total Bases

Player Bet Result Closing odds
A.J. Ewing Alternate lines 1
Alt: O1.5 +230 Miss · O2.5 +500 Miss · O3.5 +850 Miss · O4.5 +2000 Miss
Aaron Judge Under 1.5 3 — Miss -126 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 -106 Hit · O2.5 +158 Hit · O3.5 +204 Miss · O4.5 +418 Miss
Amed Rosario Alternate lines 2
Alt: O1.5 +185 Hit · O2.5 +500 Miss · O3.5 +950 Miss · O4.5 +1900 Miss
Anthony Volpe Alternate lines 0
Alt: O1.5 +180 Miss · O2.5 +420 Miss · O3.5 +650 Miss · O4.5 +1400 Miss
Austin Slater Alternate lines 0
Alt: O1.5 +266 Miss · O2.5 +513 Miss · O3.5 +700 Miss · O4.5 +1700 Miss
Austin Wells Alternate lines 1
Alt: O1.5 +255 Miss · O2.5 +513 Miss · O3.5 +670 Miss · O4.5 +1700 Miss
Ben Rice Under 1.5 0 — Hit -160 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +120 Miss · O2.5 +230 Miss · O3.5 +315 Miss · O4.5 +650 Miss
Bo Bichette Under 1.5 0 — Hit -139 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +106 Miss · O2.5 +250 Miss · O3.5 +440 Miss · O4.5 +900 Miss
Brett Baty Alternate lines 2
Alt: O1.5 +210 Hit · O2.5 +500 Miss · O3.5 +800 Miss · O4.5 +1800 Miss
Carson Benge Alternate lines 4
Alt: O1.5 +157 Hit · O2.5 +366 Hit · O3.5 +650 Hit · O4.5 +1500 Miss
Cody Bellinger Under 1.5 0 — Hit -170 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +128 Miss · O2.5 +278 Miss · O3.5 +445 Miss · O4.5 +850 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Alternate lines 3
Alt: O1.5 +195 Hit · O2.5 +381 Hit · O3.5 +508 Miss · O4.5 +1200 Miss
Juan Soto Alternate lines 2
Alt: O1.5 +136 Hit · O2.5 +256 Miss · O3.5 +340 Miss · O4.5 +750 Miss
Luis Torrens Alternate lines 0
Alt: O1.5 +210 Miss · O2.5 +500 Miss · O3.5 +750 Miss · O4.5 +1800 Miss
Marcus Semien Alternate lines 0
Alt: O1.5 +155 Miss · O2.5 +330 Miss · O3.5 +500 Miss · O4.5 +1200 Miss
Mark Vientos Under 1.5 2 — Miss -167 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +135 Hit · O2.5 +270 Miss · O3.5 +370 Miss · O4.5 +900 Miss
Paul Goldschmidt Alternate lines 2
Alt: O1.5 +147 Hit · O2.5 +310 Miss · O3.5 +450 Miss · O4.5 +950 Miss
Trent Grisham Alternate lines 1
Alt: O1.5 +167 Miss · O2.5 +315 Miss · O3.5 +411 Miss · O4.5 +960 Miss

Runs Scored

Player Bet Result Closing odds
A.J. Ewing Under 0.5 0 — Hit -246 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +175 Miss · O1.5 +1500 Miss
Aaron Judge Under 0.5 1 — Miss -102 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -136 Hit · O1.5 +400 Miss · O2.5 +1900 Miss
Amed Rosario Under 0.5 0 — Hit -270 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +190 Miss · O1.5 +1300 Miss · O2.5 +8000 Miss
Anthony Volpe Under 0.5 0 — Hit -218 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +165 Miss · O1.5 +1100 Miss · O2.5 +7500 Miss
Austin Slater Under 0.5 1 — Miss -284 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +199 Hit · O1.5 +1300 Miss
Austin Wells Under 0.5 0 — Hit -259 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +183 Miss · O1.5 +1000 Miss · O2.5 +6500 Miss
Ben Rice Under 0.5 1 — Miss -124 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -111 Hit · O1.5 +400 Miss · O2.5 +2000 Miss
Bo Bichette Under 0.5 2 — Miss -151 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +109 Hit · O1.5 +750 Hit · O2.5 +4500 Miss
Brett Baty Under 0.5 0 — Hit -251 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +180 Miss · O1.5 +1500 Miss
Carson Benge Under 0.5 2 — Miss -167 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +120 Hit · O1.5 +900 Hit · O2.5 +5500 Miss
Cody Bellinger Under 0.5 0 — Hit -182 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +131 Miss · O1.5 +800 Miss · O2.5 +4500 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Under 0.5 1 — Miss -223 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +159 Hit · O1.5 +1100 Miss · O2.5 +7000 Miss
Juan Soto Under 0.5 1 — Miss -141 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +102 Hit · O1.5 +700 Miss · O2.5 +4000 Miss
Luis Torrens Under 0.5 0 — Hit -244 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +175 Miss · O1.5 +1500 Miss
Marcus Semien Under 0.5 0 — Hit -190 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +145 Miss · O1.5 +1100 Miss · O2.5 +8000 Miss
Mark Vientos Under 0.5 0 — Hit -178 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +128 Miss · O1.5 +950 Miss · O2.5 +7000 Miss
Paul Goldschmidt Under 0.5 0 — Hit -166 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +140 Miss · O1.5 +1000 Miss · O2.5 +5500 Miss
Trent Grisham Under 0.5 0 — Hit -197 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +141 Miss · O1.5 +850 Miss · O2.5 +5500 Miss

RBIs

Player Bet Result Closing odds
A.J. Ewing Under 0.5 0 — Hit -388 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +265 Miss · O1.5 +900 Miss · O2.5 +2700 Miss · O3.5 +8000 Miss
Aaron Judge Under 0.5 0 — Hit -171 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +125 Miss · O1.5 +365 Miss · O2.5 +940 Miss · O3.5 +2000 Miss
Amed Rosario Under 0.5 0 — Hit -388 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +265 Miss · O1.5 +900 Miss · O2.5 +2700 Miss · O3.5 +8000 Miss
Anthony Volpe Under 0.5 0 — Hit -355 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +244 Miss · O1.5 +750 Miss · O2.5 +2200 Miss · O3.5 +6500 Miss
Austin Slater Under 0.5 0 — Hit -429 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +290 Miss · O1.5 +850 Miss · O2.5 +2200 Miss · O3.5 +8000 Miss
Austin Wells Under 0.5 0 — Hit -333 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +250 Miss · O1.5 +850 Miss · O2.5 +2500 Miss · O3.5 +7500 Miss
Ben Rice Under 0.5 0 — Hit -257 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +181 Miss · O1.5 +595 Miss · O2.5 +1500 Miss · O3.5 +4000 Miss
Bo Bichette Under 0.5 0 — Hit -282 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +198 Miss · O1.5 +650 Miss · O2.5 +2200 Miss · O3.5 +6000 Miss
Brett Baty Under 0.5 1 — Miss -362 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +249 Hit · O1.5 +800 Miss · O2.5 +2200 Miss · O3.5 +6000 Miss
Carson Benge Under 0.5 0 — Hit -397 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +271 Miss · O1.5 +900 Miss · O2.5 +3000 Miss · O3.5 +8000 Miss
Cody Bellinger Under 0.5 0 — Hit -267 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +188 Miss · O1.5 +574 Miss · O2.5 +1400 Miss · O3.5 +3000 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Under 0.5 0 — Hit -318 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +221 Miss · O1.5 +630 Miss · O2.5 +1600 Miss · O3.5 +4000 Miss
Juan Soto Under 0.5 0 — Hit -234 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +166 Miss · O1.5 +500 Miss · O2.5 +1400 Miss · O3.5 +4000 Miss
Luis Torrens Under 0.5 0 — Hit -354 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +244 Miss · O1.5 +800 Miss · O2.5 +2200 Miss · O3.5 +8000 Miss
Marcus Semien Under 0.5 0 — Hit -279 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +199 Miss · O1.5 +600 Miss · O2.5 +1700 Miss · O3.5 +5000 Miss
Mark Vientos Under 0.5 3 — Miss -216 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +160 Hit · O1.5 +490 Hit · O2.5 +1300 Hit · O3.5 +3500 Miss
Paul Goldschmidt Under 0.5 1 — Miss -225 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +164 Hit · O1.5 +480 Miss · O2.5 +1300 Miss · O3.5 +3000 Miss
Trent Grisham Under 0.5 1 — Miss -293 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 +205 Hit · O1.5 +600 Miss · O2.5 +1800 Miss · O3.5 +4500 Miss

Stolen Bases

Player Bet Result Closing odds
A.J. Ewing Over 0.5 0 — Miss +559 DraftKings · 2 books
Under 0.5 0 — Hit -920 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +5500 Miss
Aaron Judge Over 0.5 0 — Miss +920 FanDuel
Amed Rosario Over 0.5 0 — Miss +700 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +10000 Miss
Anthony Volpe Over 0.5 0 — Miss +630 FanDuel · 2 books
Under 0.5 0 — Hit -1060 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +8000 Miss
Austin Slater Over 0.5 0 — Miss +920 FanDuel
Ben Rice Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1200 FanDuel
Bo Bichette Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1400 FanDuel
Brett Baty Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1400 FanDuel
Carson Benge Over 0.5 0 — Miss +710 DraftKings · 2 books
Under 0.5 0 — Hit -1260 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +7500 Miss
Cody Bellinger Over 0.5 0 — Miss +750 FanDuel
Alt: O1.5 +10000 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Over 0.5 0 — Miss +474 DraftKings · 2 books
Under 0.5 0 — Hit -760 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +4000 Miss
Juan Soto Over 0.5 2 — Hit +580 FanDuel · 2 books
Under 0.5 2 — Miss -920 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +5500 Hit
Marcus Semien Over 0.5 0 — Miss +750 FanDuel · 2 books
Under 0.5 0 — Hit -1160 DraftKings
Alt: O1.5 +10000 Miss
Mark Vientos Over 0.5 0 — Miss +2200 FanDuel
Paul Goldschmidt Over 0.5 0 — Miss +920 FanDuel
Trent Grisham Over 0.5 0 — Miss +1000 FanDuel

Hits + Runs + RBIs

Player Bet Result Closing odds
A.J. Ewing Under 1.5 1 — Hit -187 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -187 Hit · O1.5 +145 Miss · O2.5 +310 Miss · O3.5 +650 Miss
Aaron Judge Under 1.5 3 — Miss +115 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -384 Hit · O1.5 -152 Hit · O2.5 +116 Hit · O3.5 +209 Miss
Amed Rosario Under 1.5 1 — Hit -166 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -206 Hit · O1.5 +125 Miss · O2.5 +265 Miss · O3.5 +550 Miss
Anthony Volpe Under 1.5 0 — Hit -150 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -220 Miss · O1.5 +120 Miss · O2.5 +250 Miss · O3.5 +500 Miss
Austin Slater Under 0.5 1 — Miss -101 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -131 Hit · O1.5 +180 Miss · O2.5 +344 Miss · O3.5 +670 Miss
Austin Wells Under 0.5 1 — Miss +119 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -159 Hit · O1.5 +152 Miss · O2.5 +305 Miss · O3.5 +586 Miss
Ben Rice Under 1.5 1 — Hit -102 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -316 Hit · O1.5 -130 Miss · O2.5 +152 Miss · O3.5 +294 Miss
Bo Bichette Under 1.5 2 — Miss +106 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -370 Hit · O1.5 -139 Hit · O2.5 +155 Miss · O3.5 +310 Miss
Brett Baty Under 1.5 2 — Miss -176 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -190 Hit · O1.5 +135 Hit · O2.5 +290 Miss · O3.5 +600 Miss
Carson Benge Under 1.5 5 — Miss -137 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -264 Hit · O1.5 +103 Hit · O2.5 +222 Hit · O3.5 +450 Hit
Cody Bellinger Under 1.5 0 — Hit -113 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -311 Miss · O1.5 -116 Miss · O2.5 +177 Miss · O3.5 +335 Miss
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Under 1.5 3 — Miss -170 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -180 Hit · O1.5 +129 Hit · O2.5 +248 Hit · O3.5 +476 Miss
Juan Soto Under 1.5 3 — Miss -126 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -266 Hit · O1.5 -106 Hit · O2.5 +175 Hit · O3.5 +322 Miss
Luis Torrens Under 1.5 0 — Hit -165 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -195 Miss · O1.5 +135 Miss · O2.5 +290 Miss · O3.5 +600 Miss
Marcus Semien Under 1.5 0 — Hit -138 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -241 Miss · O1.5 +105 Miss · O2.5 +210 Miss · O3.5 +430 Miss
Mark Vientos Under 1.5 4 — Miss -117 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -262 Hit · O1.5 -105 Hit · O2.5 +185 Hit · O3.5 +360 Hit
Paul Goldschmidt Under 1.5 3 — Miss -122 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -270 Hit · O1.5 -109 Hit · O2.5 +180 Hit · O3.5 +350 Miss
Trent Grisham Under 1.5 2 — Miss -156 DraftKings
Alt: O0.5 -201 Hit · O1.5 +117 Hit · O2.5 +218 Miss · O3.5 +417 Miss

Strikeouts

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Carlos Rodon Under 5.5 -143 DraftKings · 2 books
Alt: O2.5 -1380 · O3.5 -450 · O4.5 -189 · O5.5 +112

Outs Recorded

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Carlos Rodon Over 16.5 -113 DraftKings · 2 books
Under 16.5 -114 FanDuel · 2 books

Walks Allowed

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Carlos Rodon Over 2.5 +141 DraftKings
Under 2.5 -189 DraftKings

Earned Runs

Player Bet Result Closing odds
Carlos Rodon Over 2.5 +115 DraftKings
Under 2.5 -152 DraftKings

Game Lines

Moneyline

Selection Result Closing odds
NYM Hit +105 DraftKings · 2 books
NYY Miss -122 FanDuel · 2 books

Run Line

Selection Result Closing odds
NYM -1.5 Hit +210 FanDuel · 2 books
NYM -1 Hit +150 DraftKings
NYM +1 Hit -131 DraftKings
NYY -1.5 Miss +138 FanDuel · 2 books
NYY -1 Miss +101 DraftKings
NYY +1 Miss -198 DraftKings

Total

Selection Result Closing odds
Over 4.5 9 — Hit -790 DraftKings
Over 5 9 — Hit -690 DraftKings
Over 5.5 9 — Hit -374 DraftKings
Under 4.5 9 — Miss +468 DraftKings
Under 5 9 — Miss +421 DraftKings
Under 5.5 9 — Miss +263 DraftKings

Closing lines captured at the last pre-game snapshot; results from the official box score. Odds shown are the best available price across sportsbooks at that time. This is a historical record, not betting advice.